the AI LIVE manifesto.
Worth Watching
written live, every tuesday, since march 2023.
put to the vote, like everything else.
what this is
The machines can make anything now. Any shot, any face, any world, in about four minutes.
So "can it be made?" is a boring question. We're interested in a better one:
Is it worth watching?
Every week we put the best AI creative in front of a live audience and you vote on it. 1, 2 or 3. No hiding. This is what all those votes have taught us.
belief one
slop is going to look incredible. it's still slop.
The same tool that makes slop makes masterpieces. Same model, same credits, same prompt box.
The difference was never the tool. It's the person holding it.
belief two
story beats spectacle.
Every model can make a beautiful shot now. So a beautiful shot doesn't win the vote any more.
The pieces at the top of the rankings have an idea you could pitch in one sentence, and a payoff at the end.
Pretty is free. Story is the work.
belief three
taste is the new technical skill.
Anyone can make the thing. Knowing which of the 200 versions is the good one is the job.
Taste is the filter. Train it like a muscle. Watch more. Judge more. Say why.
belief four
ideas are the new budget.
The technology has finally caught up with our ideas. What we can think about, we can make.
That spec ad no client would green-light? Make it anyway. That silly idea you've had since you were twelve? It doesn't have to stay a silly idea.
belief five
credit the humans.
It's not the AI making it. It's never been the AI making it.
Behind every piece we show is a person who had the idea, chose the shots, cut the edit and stayed up until 3am fixing hands. We say their names. Out loud. Every time.
belief six
use AI where it makes sense.
Real actors. Real cameras. Real sets. AI in the gaps, where it adds something.
The best compliment we can give a piece is "forget the AI, that was just a good ad".
belief seven
sound is half the picture.
Models treat sound as an afterthought. Audiences don't.
A real score, real foley and a properly directed voice will move a piece from a 2 to a 1 faster than any upscale.
belief eight
the edit is still the craft.
Generating the shots is half the job. The other half is cutting them like a film: rhythm, restraint, and a reason for every cut.
If it could be told in half the time, it should have been.
belief nine
the audience is the filter.
The algorithm doesn't know what good storytelling is. You do.
That's the whole point of the show. Your live vote makes a better filter, so the great stuff gets found and the people who made it get seen by the right person.
belief ten
nobody's job got replaced. the tool belt got bigger.
The people we show haven't stopped being directors, editors, animators and writers. They've just got more in their tool belt.
Your camera is now an infinite lens. Point it at something worth watching.
what gets a 3
- another polished dystopia
- another celebrity fight scene
- a face that changes every shot
- music bolted on at the end
- "made with AI" as the whole idea
- beautiful, and about nothing
what gets a 1
- a twist you didn't see coming
- a laugh out loud on the train
- sound you can feel
- characters you'd follow anywhere
- a reason for every cut
- the human's name in the credits
This will be wrong in six months. The models will change. The vote won't.
Make the thing. Put it out there. We'll put it to the vote.
Chris & Andrew
live every tuesday, 4pm UK
Directed by Chris & Andrew. Words by Chris & Andrew, drafted with Claude from what they've said on the show. Pictures made with Magnific under their direction. Built with Claude Code.