Guide · from 241 live votes

What makes an AI film worth watching?

Every week the AI LIVE audience votes on the best new AI films, ads and music videos, and every week the hosts explain why a piece landed or did not. These are the lessons that keep coming back, in the hosts' own words, with the pieces that prove them.

Across 241 pieces put to the live vote on 19 episodes, the average score is 82/100 and 63 scored a perfect 100. By type: AI films 84/100, AI ads 78/100, AI music videos 81/100, AI trailers 79/100, AI animations 90/100 and AI series episodes 79/100.

1. Story beats spectacle

Every model can now make a beautiful shot, so a beautiful shot no longer wins the vote. The pieces at the top of the rankings have an idea you could pitch in one sentence and a payoff at the end.

Story beats spectacle. I LIVED was not the strongest piece visually, but its voiceover, music and restraint earned 12 1s, while for long series the test is simple: are the first five minutes watchable enough to buy you in?
Ep. 127, 4 Aug 2026
Stunning visuals are now the baseline, so story is what sticks. Before Sunrise looked flawless but left Chris wanting a narrative, while the F1 toy car animation won the room through pure visual imagination.
Ep. 113, 17 Mar 2026
Story still wins the vote. Spare, a Kling 4 early access short about a man who keeps ordering clones of his partner, topped the night with ten 1s, just ahead of Candy.
Ep. 132, 29 Sept 2026

Films that prove it

  1. 1Untitled Pigeon AnimationMarko Slavnic · Ep. 120, 12 May 2026 · AI animation100
  2. 2SPECTRALThe Butcher's Brain · Ep. 123, 16 Jun 2026 · AI film100
  3. 3OvertureDave Clark · Ep. 120, 12 May 2026 · AI film100

2. Originality beats polish

The audience has seen every polished dystopia and every celebrity fight scene. A fresh premise, a twist or a genuine laugh does more for the vote than another perfect frame.

Originality beat polish. Andrew's point was that a well-made sci-fi trailer scores high if it's the first one you see and low after a dozen similar ones, and the top of the vote went to the films with a different angle: extinct dogs in Liberator, whale song in The Pattern.
Ep. 130, 1 Sept 2026
A familiar story with a fresh twist beats another dystopia. Minutes after Andrew asked for new twists on stories we already know, RED! reimagined Little Red Riding Hood and led the night with 13 straight 1s, while 404 Films summed up the room on sci-fi: brilliant execution, but we're all a bit overcooked on it.
Ep. 124, 30 Jun 2026
Comedy is the one reliable way through. Andrew said early on that only comedy gets away with a purely positive future, and Bizarre Bunny's Inkom proved it at the end of the show by breaking a long run of heavy films with proper jokes.
Ep. 130, 1 Sept 2026

Films that prove it

  1. 1HOLY GRAiLMarco Magario · Ep. 119, 5 May 2026 · AI film100
  2. 2Prince of ChaosZ Khan · Ep. 123, 16 Jun 2026 · AI film100
  3. 3BewareSam Stephens · Ep. 124, 30 Jun 2026 · AI film100

3. Sound and music decide the score

AI video models still treat sound as an afterthought, and audiences notice. A real score, foley and well-directed voices are what move a piece from a 2 to a 1.

Sound design is what separates good from great. SPECTRAL lost points only for thin foley between lines of dialogue, while Dave Clark's horror short showed how in-between sounds keep you immersed. Chris's argument: sound is 60% of the experience.
Ep. 123, 16 Jun 2026
Sound still decides how a piece lands. Andrew Miller's voiceover, the piano and violin in In Another Breath and Dave Clark's Suno beat were the details Chris kept coming back to, because audio can make or break a piece.
Ep. 117, 14 Apr 2026
Music still decides whether AI film lands. ABEL scored well, but both hosts said the score and the edit are what move a piece from a 2 to a 1, and audio is still the hardest part to control.
Ep. 134, 13 Oct 2026

Films that prove it

  1. 1What's the Job?Jacopo Zanetti · Ep. 136, 27 Oct 2026 · AI film100
  2. 2RED!Lauren Indovina · Ep. 124, 30 Jun 2026 · AI film100
  3. 3The WellDorian, Daniel · Ep. 125, 7 Jul 2026 · AI film100

4. The edit still matters

Generating the shots is only half the job. The best AI films are cut like any other film, with rhythm, restraint and a reason for every shot.

The edit is still where the craft lives. Yonatan's timeline was full of manual work, from flickering lights that hide a frame-to-frame join to trimming stray characters, and Chris's answer to the best skill of the Seedance era was editing to the beat.
Ep. 109, 19 Feb 2026
Editing beats regenerating. Seedance 2.0 can now change an eye, the weather or a whole animal inside existing footage and leave the rest of the shot alone, which turns AI video from a slot machine into something you can fine-tune.
Ep. 111, 3 Mar 2026
Edit around AI's weaknesses. Naveen Kumar's 1-second rule says never hold an AI shot longer than a second if you can help it, because visual quality is incredible but temporal consistency still isn't. The chat agreed most AI shots run too long.
Ep. 117, 14 Apr 2026

Films that prove it

  1. 1The Adventures of Reemo Green: Breaking Into Black HolesNeural Viz · Ep. 120, 12 May 2026 · AI series100
  2. 2Death Lane (Preview)The Dor Brothers · Ep. 118, 24 Apr 2026 · AI film100
  3. 3LiberatorAji B · Ep. 130, 1 Sept 2026 · AI film100

5. Consistent characters build trust

Viewers forgive a lot, but not a face that changes from shot to shot. Consistent characters and believable performances are what let an audience care.

Character sheets beat a face shot. Yonatan Dor's tip for Seedance 2.0 is to give the model every angle of a character, because once they're running or jumping it needs to know how they look from all sides.
Ep. 109, 19 Feb 2026
Character consistency is where AI undercuts VFX. Octo Blues kept one octopus consistent from shot to shot, which Chris said would be extraordinarily expensive in CGI, and it was the first piece of the night to draw straight 1s.
Ep. 120, 12 May 2026
Consistency is now a given, voice is the gap. Andrew noticed the show barely talks about consistency any more, but AI voices still sound average and AI-ish, and both hosts expect audio to be what makes work stand out.
Ep. 136, 27 Oct 2026

Films that prove it

  1. 1Octo BluesStéphane Tranquillin · Ep. 120, 12 May 2026 · AI film100
  2. 2They Came When We LeftJustinas Vosylius, Metamotion · Ep. 135, 20 Oct 2026 · AI film100
  3. 3NORM 20The Dor Brothers · Ep. 120, 12 May 2026 · AI film100

6. Use AI where it makes sense

The hosts' rule is to use AI where it adds something. Hybrid work that mixes real footage, real actors and AI effects often lands better than fully synthetic pieces, and draws less backlash.

Keep AI away from the part you love. MetaPuppet writes and edits himself and uses AI for production, the one stage he had no background in. If AI replaces the thing you're passionate about, he asked, what's the point?
Ep. 110, 26 Feb 2026
Hybrid production answers the 'no humans' objection. Serviceplan Cologne's Indeed ad kept real actors, props, sets and cameras and used AI in the role CGI would normally play, which the chat saw as the likely future for big brands.
Ep. 118, 24 Apr 2026
The best AI ads don't read as AI. The Maserati film by a two-person team could run on TV without anyone asking how it was made, and at the highest level that is exactly the goal.
Ep. 133, 6 Oct 2026

Films that prove it

  1. 1Seedance 2.5 "AI Performances" ExplorationsBilly Boman · Ep. 128, 11 Aug 2026 · AI film100
  2. 2The InterviewVinu Joseph, Harsh Tiwari · Ep. 121, 26 May 2026 · AI film100
  3. 3The Patchwright (Cyberpunk Short Film)Gossip Goblin · Ep. 120, 12 May 2026 · AI animation95

Questions people ask

What makes a good AI film?

On the evidence of the AI LIVE live vote: story beats spectacle, originality beats polish, sound and music decide the score, the edit still matters, consistent characters build trust and use ai where it makes sense. Every model can now make a beautiful shot, so a beautiful shot no longer wins the vote. The pieces at the top of the rankings have an idea you could pitch in one sentence and a payoff at the end.

What score does a typical AI film get on AI LIVE?

Across 241 pieces put to the live vote on 19 episodes, the average score is 82/100 and 63 scored a perfect 100. By type: AI films 84/100, AI ads 78/100, AI music videos 81/100, AI trailers 79/100, AI animations 90/100 and AI series episodes 79/100. The live audience votes 1 for awesome, 2 for okay and 3 for not for me, and the score counts a 1 fully and a 2 as half.

What is the best AI film right now?

On the AI LIVE live vote it is Octo Blues by Stéphane Tranquillin, which scored 100/100 from 22 live votes on AI LIVE Episode 120 (12 May 2026). Octo is a giant octopus in New York who is brilliant at everything, from basketball to a 12-minute tasting menu, but never accepted.

How can I get my AI work featured on AI LIVE?

Submit it through the form at theailiveshow.com. Every Tuesday at 4pm UK the hosts review the best submissions live on LinkedIn and YouTube, and every piece goes to a live audience vote: 1 for awesome, 2 for okay, 3 for not for me.

The rankings

Best AI filmsBest AI adsAI music videosAI trailersAI animationAI series

Want your work in the ranking?

Every Tuesday at 4pm UK we review the best AI creative live and put it to the audience vote. Send us yours.

Submit your work →Every episode